Too Close, Too Far

Earlier essays in this series described how people come to include one another in their sense of self, why differentiation keeps that inclusion safe, and how groups move through a life cycle of forming, storming, norming, performing, and adjourning. This essay brings those threads together around a single idea from Murray Bowen’s family systems theory.

Bowen described two ways differentiation fails. In fusion, people lose their separate edges, so that one person’s anxiety becomes everyone’s anxiety and disagreement feels intolerable. In emotional cutoff, people manage that same intensity by withdrawing or severing ties, which can look like independence while the underlying reactivity stays unresolved (Kerr & Bowen, 1988). Fusion and cutoff look like opposites. Bowen saw them as two answers to the same problem: closeness that feels too intense to bear with a separate self intact.

Online peer communities are especially fertile ground for both. Every stage of a group’s life offers a chance to drift toward one pole or the other, and the tools of online life make each drift easier. Understanding how this happens gives members, facilitators, and organizations a way to notice it early and respond with care.

Two Forces in Every Group

Kerr and Bowen (1988) describe two life forces operating in every relationship system:

The togetherness force draws people toward connection, agreement, and shared feeling.

The individuality force draws each person toward their own thinking, direction, and choices.

Healthy systems hold both. When anxiety rises, the balance tips. Some people and groups lean hard into togetherness until everyone must feel and think alike. Others escape the pull of togetherness by leaving, going silent, or cutting ties.

Bowen also observed that anxious systems tend to form triangles. When tension between two people becomes uncomfortable, one or both draw in a third person to absorb it, often by talking about the absent party instead of speaking with them directly (Kerr & Bowen, 1988). Triangles can calm a moment while keeping the original tension unresolved. Online, triangles form easily through private messages, side channels, and screenshots shared with friends.

Stephen Karpman’s (1968) drama triangle describes three roles people fall into during conflict: the Persecutor, the Victim, and the Rescuer. People rarely stay in one role. Someone who begins as a Rescuer may come to feel used and turn into a Persecutor, or may collapse into feeling like a Victim when the help isn’t appreciated, and the drama keeps going as everyone rotates through the positions.

Laura Brown (2015) added a fourth role that survivors of childhood abuse know all too well: the complicit bystander. This is the one who sees what is happening and does nothing, whose silence lets the harm continue. For many survivors, the bystander was a parent, sibling, teacher, or congregation, and that betrayal can wound as deeply as the abuse itself.

The fourth role clarifies the double bind I described earlier. Whenever a group needed redirection, I was pulled toward the Persecutor role as the enforcing parent, and the only alternative seemed to be the complicit bystander who let harm unfold. Online communities are especially prone to this four-cornered drama. Members cast one another as villains and rescuers in comment threads, while many others watch silently, and that watching can feel to the person being targeted like the same abandonment they once survived.

For survivors, these patterns carry history. Many grew up in families where fusion was required for safety, where cutoff was the only way to survive, or where both alternated without warning. Those adaptations were intelligent responses to impossible conditions. In community, they can resurface automatically, especially under stress.

Why Online Spaces Intensify Both

Suler (2004) described the online disinhibition effect, in which people disclose or act out more frequently or intensely online than they would in person. Several of the factors he identified bear directly on fusion and cutoff. Invisibility and asynchronicity remove the facial cues and real-time feedback that usually slow escalation. Dissociative imagination can make online life feel separate from ordinary life, so that people engage with an intensity they would not bring into a room.

Platform design adds its own pressures. Notifications, constant availability, and endless scrolling invite fusion by keeping members immersed in each other’s distress at all hours. Mute, block, leave, and delete buttons make cutoff a single click. Neither tool is harmful by itself, and both are sometimes necessary. The risk lies in using them reactively, as a way to escape anxiety without ever working through it.

Online communities also invite hypercommunication: a constant stream of messages, rapid replies, late-night threads, and detailed updates on every shift in mood or circumstance. Because it is so frequent and so personal, hypercommunication can feel like intimacy, and many members mistake one for the other. Intimacy grows from being known over time, through attunement, reciprocity, respected boundaries, and the experience of repair after rupture.

Hypercommunication can happen with none of these. A person can share hundreds of messages with someone and still feel unseen, because the exchange is driven more by anxiety than by mutual knowing. In this way, hypercommunication often works as fusion’s online form, a way of staying constantly connected to avoid the discomfort of separateness. It also tends to set up cutoff, since a relationship sustained at that intensity is hard to maintain, and when the messages stop, the silence can feel like abandonment. Real intimacy can tolerate quiet. It allows each person to step away, attend to their own life and internal world, and return without the relationship being lost.

Fusion and Cutoff Across the Life of a Group

Tuckman’s (1965) stages, with the adjourning stage added by Tuckman and Jensen (1977), offer a map for seeing where each pattern tends to appear.

Forming. Fusion shows up as instant intimacy. New members may share their most painful material in the first week, receive an outpouring of warmth, and feel they have finally found home. That feeling can be real and also fragile, because trust formed that quickly has not yet been tested. Cutoff shows up as permanent lurking or a single post followed by silence. Some newcomers watch from a distance because closeness has always meant danger, and the group never learns they were there.

Storming. Conflict is where both patterns flare most intensely. Fusion appears as the pile-on, when distress spreads through a thread and members take sides almost reflexively, or as a demand that everyone share the same reaction to a disagreement. Cutoff appears as ghosting, blocking, rage-quitting, or quietly leaving after a conflict no one acknowledged. At the group level, cutoff can look like a split into a new group formed by members who left together, carrying the unresolved conflict with them. Triangles multiply during storming as members process conflict in private messages with others who were not involved.

Norming. A fused group develops a rigid orthodoxy. There is one correct way to talk about trauma, one acceptable view of a treatment approach, one right vocabulary for multiplicity, and members who differ feel pressure to conform or be quiet. A group leaning toward cutoff enforces norms by removal, so that the main response to a violated norm is exclusion, without conversation or repair.

Performing. A mature group can drift toward fusion when the community becomes a member’s entire support system, when people feel responsible for one another’s crises around the clock, or when a member’s sense of self rests on the group’s approval. For members with para-social attachments to a host or founder, fusion can attach to that one person. Cutoff in this stage looks like slow drift. Members who never felt fully seen fade away, and no one notices the absence. This can also be used as a “cut off” against those who stayed, but set healthy boundaries.

Adjourning. Fused groups struggle to let anyone go. Leaving is experienced as betrayal, and those who step away may be talked about or shut out. Groups prone to cutoff end abruptly. A facilitator leaves without explanation, a group dissolves without a final meeting, or a member disappears and the absence is never named. Unacknowledged endings leave the grief of the group unprocessed.

Fusion and Cutoff in Dissociative Systems

For folks with dissociative capacities, these dynamics can unfold inside the system as well as between the system and the group. One part may fuse with the group, eager to belong and disclose, while another part is ready to cut off, alarmed by exposure. A member may post deeply personal material and then delete it hours later, or vanish after a moment of closeness that some parts welcomed and others did not. These swings are communication from within the system. Groups that understand this can respond with patience and without judgment, and can leave the door open for the whole system to return when it is ready.

Differentiation sits between fusion and cutoff. It allows people to stay connected while keeping their own perceptions, to be moved without being swept away, and to step back without severing ties. Skowron and Friedlander (1998) found that lower emotional reactivity, less fusion and cutoff, and a stronger ability to take an “I position” predicted lower chronic anxiety and better psychological adjustment. The following practices draw on that research and on the essays in this series.

For members. Speak from an I position: “This is how I see it,” “This is what I need,” “I’m going to step back for a while.” Notice whose feelings are whose. When another member’s pain lands in your body, Singer and Klimecki (2014) suggest that compassion, a warm concern that keeps track of the other person as separate, sustains people better than empathic distress. Use the pause that asynchronicity offers: draft, wait, and reread before posting into a conflict. Choose distance with a word, so that stepping back sounds like “I’m taking a break and I’ll be back”. Keep relationships and supports outside the community, including therapy, so the group is one source of care among many. Before discussing a conflict with a third person, ask whether a direct conversation is possible.

For facilitators and moderators. Edwin Friedman (1985), building on Bowen, described the value of a leader who stays connected to the group while managing their own anxiety, sometimes called a non-anxious presence. Calm, steady facilitation lowers the anxiety of a whole system. Slow conflicts down. Move heated exchanges from public threads into a structured conversation, and bring parties together directly when that is safe, and avoid carrying messages between them. Name endings and departures openly. Watch for both poles: the member who is disclosing too much too fast and the member who has gone quiet. Facilitators need their own support and supervision so they do not become fused with the community they serve.

For organizations. Write norms down and apply them consistently. Build a process for concerns that leads toward repair before removal, while protecting members from real harm. Make leaving and returning normal by stating clearly that members can take breaks and remain welcome. Create rituals for endings, such as final group meetings and acknowledgments when facilitators transition. Offer more than one point of contact so no single relationship becomes the center of anyone’s safety. Educate members about online disinhibition, para-social dynamics, and the tools of the platform, so they can use mute and leave functions as deliberate choices.

So, fusion and cutoff are both attempts to survive closeness that feels too intense. For many survivors, they were once the only options available. A healthy online community offers a third possibility: belonging that leaves room for a separate self, and distance that leaves the relationship intact. Online tools will keep making it easy to merge or to vanish. Communities that understand these patterns can help members find their way back to the middle, where people can disagree and stay, rest and return, and remain fully themselves while being part of something larger.

References

Bowen, M. (1978). Family therapy in clinical practice. Jason Aronson.

Brown, L. S. (2015). Not the price of admission: Healthy relationships after childhood trauma. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.

Friedman, E. H. (1985). Generation to generation: Family process in church and synagogue. Guilford Press.

Karpman, S. B. (1968). Fairy tales and script drama analysis. Transactional Analysis Bulletin, 7(26), 39-43.

Kerr, M. E., & Bowen, M. (1988). Family evaluation: An approach based on Bowen theory. W. W. Norton.

Singer, T., & Klimecki, O. M. (2014). Empathy and compassion. Current Biology, 24(18), R875-R878. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2014.06.054

Skowron, E. A., & Friedlander, M. L. (1998). The Differentiation of Self Inventory: Development and initial validation. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 45(3), 235-246. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0167.45.3.235

Suler, J. (2004). The online disinhibition effect. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 7(3), 321-326. https://doi.org/10.1089/1094931041291295

Tuckman, B. W. (1965). Developmental sequence in small groups. Psychological Bulletin, 63(6), 384-399. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0022100

Tuckman, B. W., & Jensen, M. A. C. (1977). Stages of small-group development revisited. Group & Organization Studies, 2(4), 419-427. https://doi.org/10.1177/105960117700200404

Emma Sunshaw, PhD

Executive Director, S3C Foundation

https://www.s3cfoundation.org/about
Previous
Previous

Suggested Guidelines for Healthy Online Dynamics

Next
Next

The Life of a Group